Why Your Online Sales Conversions Are Dropping – And What To Do About It

The Problem: Falling Conversions Across the Digital Landscape

Online sales conversions are declining across industries, and if you haven’t felt the impact yet, you likely will soon. At DodsonMC, we’ve analyzed data from 1,000+ online publishers and just as many ad buyers, revealing key trends that are causing conversion rates to plummet. The good news? If you understand why this is happening, you can take the right steps to fix it—before it’s too late.

What’s Happening?

Here are the five biggest reasons online conversions are falling:

Economic Slowdowns Are Changing Buyer Behavior
Consumers are more cautious with their spending. With economic uncertainty, many shoppers are browsing but delaying purchases, leading to higher cart abandonment rates and longer decision cycles.
Privacy Changes Are Hurting Targeting & Retargeting
The digital ad landscape has shifted due to cookie deprecation, iOS privacy updates, and Google’s tracking changes. Traditional methods of targeting and retargeting have become less effective, making it harder to re-engage high-intent users.
Ad Fatigue & Market Saturation
With every brand fighting for attention, consumers are experiencing ad fatigue. They are less likely to engage with generic ads and are becoming more selective about where they click and what they buy.
Algorithm Changes Are Reshaping Social & Search
– Google’s AI-driven search is shifting how users discover brands.
– Meta & TikTok’s algorithm updates are making organic reach more difficult.
– New ad formats (e.g., Performance Max, AI-powered ads) are changing how brands must structure their campaigns.
Fragmentation of Media Consumption
People are no longer sticking to just one platform or device. They engage across multiple touchpoints, requiring brands to have a more sophisticated, multi-channel approach.

How This Affects Your Business

🚨 Rising Costs, Lower ROAS
With targeting issues and weaker engagement, cost-per-acquisition (CPA) is rising, and return on ad spend (ROAS) is declining.

⏳ Longer Buying Cycles
Shoppers are researching more and taking longer to convert, meaning brands need better nurturing strategies.

📉 Diminishing Organic Reach
SEO and social media require more effort to maintain visibility, as platforms push paid models over organic discovery.

What You Can Do About It – The Fix

✅ 1. Leverage Contextual & Hyperlocal Advertising
With third-party cookies disappearing, contextual and hyperlocal targeting are the best ways to stay relevant.
– Why? Consumers trust ads in local, high-quality content more than traditional banner ads.
– How? Our network at DodsonMC & EmpowerLocal connects brands to trusted local publishers, increasing relevance and engagement.

✅ 2. Strengthen First-Party Data Collection
Brands that own their audience data will have a competitive edge.

What to do:
– Capture email & SMS opt-ins via lead magnets and special offers.
– Use AI-driven personalization to serve dynamic content.
– Implement server-side tracking (CAPI, Enhanced Conversions) for better data insights.

✅ 3. Optimize for Multi-Touch Attribution
The days of single-click conversions are over.

What to do:
– Use GA4 & cross-channel tracking to see the full customer journey.
– Focus on incrementality testing to measure real ad impact.
– Adjust attribution models to reflect modern buying behavior.

✅ 4. Adapt to AI-Powered Search & Shopping
– Optimize for Google AI Overviews & AI-driven search.
– Test Performance Max campaigns & shoppable ads.
– Build rich product content to appear in AI-generated results.

✅ 5. Improve Ad Creative & Engagement
– Switch to interactive, video, and immersive ads.
– Use carousel ads & user-generated content for better social engagement.
– Ensure messaging is tailored and value-driven.

Want to Go a Step Further?

We’ve identified nine critical imperatives that will shape the next wave of successful digital marketing strategies. If you’re ready to elevate your approach, reach out to us for an engagement, and we’ll share these game-changing insights tailored to your business.

The Future of Online Conversions

The small businesses and brands that adapt NOW will win later. The key to maintaining (and growing) conversion rates is to embrace new targeting strategies, own your data, and optimize for multi-channel engagement.

💡 Need expert help to make this happen? DodsonMC has helped businesses turn conversion struggles into growth strategies. Let’s talk about how we can do the same for you.

📩 Get in touch today!

Explore Our Digital Marketing Insights

Discover expert insights on digital marketing! Click below to explore our blog for valuable strategies, trends, and perspectives to grow your business

DODSON MC